According to an October 22, 2022 Library Journal article, It Starts With Us tops all holds lists. In addition to holding that spot, it is the most pre-ordered novel of all time. If you want to find a similar book about second chances, try one of these:
Lauren, Christina. Love and Other Words.
Guillory, Jasmine. Party of Two.
Higgans, Kristan. My One and Only.
Jimenez, Abby. The Happily Ever After Playlist.
Solomon, Rachel Lynn. The Ex Talk.
For more readalikes, try NoveList Plus, available to Rockwall County Library cardholders.